Wednesday, March 08, 2006
The Truth About Ramadi
Today I received an e-mail from my father that caused me to spend some time thinking about the real situation in Iraq, particularly in light of the President's recent address to the Country. After sending my father a response, I decided that I wanted to respond, not just to him, as a son to a father, but rather to all of you that I care for and maybe more accurately as one American to my fellow Americans. All of you receiving this are friends or family that I care deeply about, and miss a great deal. I also respect all of you and know that we don't always agree on the decisions made by the leadership of our nation. In all of the discussions, debates, and sometimes heated disagreements among us, what has always remained clear in my mind is this: all of us, in the end, want what is best for our country. I will tell you that in my view what we are doing in Iraq today, and more importantly the decisions our nation's leaders make in the weeks, and months ahead about what we will do in Iraq define and will define what and who we are as Americans. In truth, I believe nothing less than the future of our country and our way of life is at stake.
I actually just got to see the President's address this morning, and I think he did a good job. I also listened to Senator Biden and a few others talk about Iraq. I have also heard my Congressman, Congressman Murtha over the last couple of weeks. Here is my opinion:
Congressman Murtha is WRONG. Moreover, some politicians in D.C. and elsewhere that are, in my opinion, using Iraq for political leverage for the upcoming elections, are not just wrong, but seriously misguided in their efforts. I know that there are many, and maybe Congressman Murtha is one of these, that have legitimate concerns, and are seeking honest and open debate about whether or not we should remain in Iraq. I think that honest and open debate is good and that this process is at the heart of what it means to live in a free society. I expect nothing less from those we have entrusted with the leadership of our nation. They must ask the hard questions. I also know that this very debate appears to lend strength to our enemies because they are able to point to it and say: "we are having success with causing the Americans to doubt themselves". Many of the enemies of freedom see our questioning of ourselves as a lack of resolve; an inability to see a thing through. Those of us that are blessed to live in a free society know that they are misguided. However, it is also the responsibility of those that would seek to engage in this debate to be educated in the reality, the facts if you will, about what is actually occurring in Iraq. Those politicians (and unfortunately, from what I have heard from him, Congressman Murtha is one of these) that claim to KNOW what the story is in Iraq and that we are not being successful, are either misled by their own staffers, or are ignoring the facts to gain political advantage in the upcoming elections.
Here is the truth in Ramadi, Iraq:
We are now, and we have been, making tremendous and yes to quote the Vice President "remarkable" progress! I have personally seen and been part of the efforts of an Iraqi Battalion that has come from a thrown together militia force to the point where they now control some of their own battlespace. Now what does that actually mean?
It means that a portion of Ramadi, Iraq that was completely lawless, with citizens that were terrified of what would happen to them if they were even suspected of supporting the coalition or the Iraqi government even two months ago now openly support the Iraqi soldiers living in their community because they provide a return of the Rule of Law and an end to the Rule of Might.
It means that the children of that small community now are able to play outside, and see their friends, and go to school, without being afraid of inadvertently being caught up in an explosion aimed at whoever happens to be in the area when the insurgents decide to initiate it.
It means that the Sunnis that live in Ramadi, those that want nothing more than an end to the violence, and that is the vast, vast majority of people here, could freely exercise their RIGHT (yes, they have RIGHTS now because of our successes) to vote for the future of their nation, and their community. Moreover, that very freedom, at least in this small part of Iraq that 3-1-7 controls, an area of Iraq that is inhabited almost exclusively by Sunni Muslims, was provided by mostly Shia Muslims. More importantly, the members of this community know that, and are extremely grateful for their presence- the presence of the Third Battalion of the First Brigade of the Seventh Division OF THE IRAQI SECURITY FORCES (regardless of their religious customs).
It means that bit by painful bit; the insurgency is being crushed by the efforts of Iraqis that truly want a free society. Not just the efforts of the soldiers, but also the Iraqi contractors that support them, and the people of the communities that support them.
It means that the quality of life for the people in this small part of Iraq is growing better on a daily basis. Water, power, roads, sewage, schools, food, all these things are getting better. Slowly, painfully, sometimes, agonizingly slowly, but consistently getting better.
It means that the Iraqi Army, under strength, under equipped, living in conditions that make the worst slums in the U.S. seem like a great place to live, are daily putting their lives at risk (and sometimes losing their lives) to safeguard the free future of their country. Why? Not for the pay (it isn't very much, and most could make enough to support their families doing something else), but because they know that the only way to ensure their families safety and freedom in the future is to stand up and be counted with those that want the Rule of Law to govern and not the Rule of Might. They are uneducated, poor, and unskilled, but they are brave, and they are dedicated, and they will WIN!
It means that Victory is attainable in Iraq. I have heard the detractors say that no one has defined Victory in Iraq. Victory in Iraq is easily defined. When the Iraqi people have attained the ability to ensure that the Rule of Law and not the Rule of Might governs their land, when children can play outside safe from senseless violence, when the Iraqi quality of life consistently gets better on a daily basis, when the Iraqi people take ownership of their problems and seek to find a solution to them even when this involves personal sacrifice, when Iraqis can put aside religious differences to work together for a better way of life, then Victory will be achieved in Iraq.
In the small part of Iraq that 3-1-7 controls, a part of Iraq that is in the very heart of the insurgent's stronghold of Ramadi, Victory is coming ever closer. We are not there yet, and they still need our help, but they are winning.
Finally it means that the only way that we will fail to gain Victory is if WE give up. If we now, as a nation, say: it is too much money, too much sacrifice, too much blood, the Iraqis that are working, sacrificing and fighting for a better way of life will fail and the Rule of Might will return to Iraq with all of the horror it can muster. Regardless of the reasons for us being here in the first place, right or wrong; we are here. We as a nation have a true obligation, and a DUTY to see this through. We, as a country, are truly living up to our ideals for one of the first times in our nation's history. We are living up to those ideals, not because we came here, but because we are willing to STAY here. We have given the Iraqi people HOPE. God save our nation if, in our selfishness, our impatience, and yes our arrogance we decide to quit now. We would make of ourselves the very thing that our enemies say we are: a people and a country unwilling and unable to live up to the standards and beliefs that we claim. I do not believe that our country is a purveyor of false hope and hypocrisy, and I do not believe that we will allow ourselves to fail in this war. We must "Stay the Course" in Iraq, just as our forefathers have in every great challenge to our Nation since its birth. Nothing less is acceptable.
I love you and miss you all. As a person, as a friend, as a nephew, as a cousin, as a son and a grandson, as a husband, and as a father, I would far prefer to be at home with my family and my friends, but as an American, there is no place I would rather be right now, than Ramadi, Iraq.
Written by Maj. M. T. Vesely - USMC
I actually just got to see the President's address this morning, and I think he did a good job. I also listened to Senator Biden and a few others talk about Iraq. I have also heard my Congressman, Congressman Murtha over the last couple of weeks. Here is my opinion:
Congressman Murtha is WRONG. Moreover, some politicians in D.C. and elsewhere that are, in my opinion, using Iraq for political leverage for the upcoming elections, are not just wrong, but seriously misguided in their efforts. I know that there are many, and maybe Congressman Murtha is one of these, that have legitimate concerns, and are seeking honest and open debate about whether or not we should remain in Iraq. I think that honest and open debate is good and that this process is at the heart of what it means to live in a free society. I expect nothing less from those we have entrusted with the leadership of our nation. They must ask the hard questions. I also know that this very debate appears to lend strength to our enemies because they are able to point to it and say: "we are having success with causing the Americans to doubt themselves". Many of the enemies of freedom see our questioning of ourselves as a lack of resolve; an inability to see a thing through. Those of us that are blessed to live in a free society know that they are misguided. However, it is also the responsibility of those that would seek to engage in this debate to be educated in the reality, the facts if you will, about what is actually occurring in Iraq. Those politicians (and unfortunately, from what I have heard from him, Congressman Murtha is one of these) that claim to KNOW what the story is in Iraq and that we are not being successful, are either misled by their own staffers, or are ignoring the facts to gain political advantage in the upcoming elections.
Here is the truth in Ramadi, Iraq:
We are now, and we have been, making tremendous and yes to quote the Vice President "remarkable" progress! I have personally seen and been part of the efforts of an Iraqi Battalion that has come from a thrown together militia force to the point where they now control some of their own battlespace. Now what does that actually mean?
It means that a portion of Ramadi, Iraq that was completely lawless, with citizens that were terrified of what would happen to them if they were even suspected of supporting the coalition or the Iraqi government even two months ago now openly support the Iraqi soldiers living in their community because they provide a return of the Rule of Law and an end to the Rule of Might.
It means that the children of that small community now are able to play outside, and see their friends, and go to school, without being afraid of inadvertently being caught up in an explosion aimed at whoever happens to be in the area when the insurgents decide to initiate it.
It means that the Sunnis that live in Ramadi, those that want nothing more than an end to the violence, and that is the vast, vast majority of people here, could freely exercise their RIGHT (yes, they have RIGHTS now because of our successes) to vote for the future of their nation, and their community. Moreover, that very freedom, at least in this small part of Iraq that 3-1-7 controls, an area of Iraq that is inhabited almost exclusively by Sunni Muslims, was provided by mostly Shia Muslims. More importantly, the members of this community know that, and are extremely grateful for their presence- the presence of the Third Battalion of the First Brigade of the Seventh Division OF THE IRAQI SECURITY FORCES (regardless of their religious customs).
It means that bit by painful bit; the insurgency is being crushed by the efforts of Iraqis that truly want a free society. Not just the efforts of the soldiers, but also the Iraqi contractors that support them, and the people of the communities that support them.
It means that the quality of life for the people in this small part of Iraq is growing better on a daily basis. Water, power, roads, sewage, schools, food, all these things are getting better. Slowly, painfully, sometimes, agonizingly slowly, but consistently getting better.
It means that the Iraqi Army, under strength, under equipped, living in conditions that make the worst slums in the U.S. seem like a great place to live, are daily putting their lives at risk (and sometimes losing their lives) to safeguard the free future of their country. Why? Not for the pay (it isn't very much, and most could make enough to support their families doing something else), but because they know that the only way to ensure their families safety and freedom in the future is to stand up and be counted with those that want the Rule of Law to govern and not the Rule of Might. They are uneducated, poor, and unskilled, but they are brave, and they are dedicated, and they will WIN!
It means that Victory is attainable in Iraq. I have heard the detractors say that no one has defined Victory in Iraq. Victory in Iraq is easily defined. When the Iraqi people have attained the ability to ensure that the Rule of Law and not the Rule of Might governs their land, when children can play outside safe from senseless violence, when the Iraqi quality of life consistently gets better on a daily basis, when the Iraqi people take ownership of their problems and seek to find a solution to them even when this involves personal sacrifice, when Iraqis can put aside religious differences to work together for a better way of life, then Victory will be achieved in Iraq.
In the small part of Iraq that 3-1-7 controls, a part of Iraq that is in the very heart of the insurgent's stronghold of Ramadi, Victory is coming ever closer. We are not there yet, and they still need our help, but they are winning.
Finally it means that the only way that we will fail to gain Victory is if WE give up. If we now, as a nation, say: it is too much money, too much sacrifice, too much blood, the Iraqis that are working, sacrificing and fighting for a better way of life will fail and the Rule of Might will return to Iraq with all of the horror it can muster. Regardless of the reasons for us being here in the first place, right or wrong; we are here. We as a nation have a true obligation, and a DUTY to see this through. We, as a country, are truly living up to our ideals for one of the first times in our nation's history. We are living up to those ideals, not because we came here, but because we are willing to STAY here. We have given the Iraqi people HOPE. God save our nation if, in our selfishness, our impatience, and yes our arrogance we decide to quit now. We would make of ourselves the very thing that our enemies say we are: a people and a country unwilling and unable to live up to the standards and beliefs that we claim. I do not believe that our country is a purveyor of false hope and hypocrisy, and I do not believe that we will allow ourselves to fail in this war. We must "Stay the Course" in Iraq, just as our forefathers have in every great challenge to our Nation since its birth. Nothing less is acceptable.
I love you and miss you all. As a person, as a friend, as a nephew, as a cousin, as a son and a grandson, as a husband, and as a father, I would far prefer to be at home with my family and my friends, but as an American, there is no place I would rather be right now, than Ramadi, Iraq.
Written by Maj. M. T. Vesely - USMC
Comments:
<< Home
Sir, I am impressed by your determination to show the resolve of your unit and it's mission. As a veteran of the Air Force and Desert Storm, and active in the Veterans of Foreign Wars,(VFW), I am going to past your comments in our organization for others to read. I Thank You for your Service, God bless you and your Brothers in uniform, and maybe someday, I will have the chance to shake your hand. Be Safe, Glenn Siple.
Dear Major, You are right on target and inspite of the false polls the leftist media like to toote, the majority of Americans are behind you all and your efforts. God Bless and keep all of you safe. Semper Fi from Cape Cod. David LEARY
Bravo to you for speaking the truth. I thought as much but never hear it on the news. I am sure your parents are very proud of you.
Becky Slot
Becky Slot
Thank you so much for your story!! I hope many read it!! We are blessed here with a Congressman that actually came back telling us we are winning! and all the 'real' things he saw there!! Mike Pence here in Indiana!! It's rare!! I hope more get stories out like this and show the TRUTH!! Thanks!! Rhonda
I believe that you will fail in your mission to establish a secure and stable Iraq, let alone anything approaching a democratic state. The real shame is not that you will fail, but that all of the efforts that you and your men exert could have better been spent improving the US rather than simply hemoraging money in Iraq. God bless you and see you home safely.
Major
Love it brother was just home on leave from Ramadi I talked with him many times, he tells the same story you do. I hope you would not be offended if we used some of your words at the Memorial Day Ceremories at the Legion
George
Ex- USAF
Love it brother was just home on leave from Ramadi I talked with him many times, he tells the same story you do. I hope you would not be offended if we used some of your words at the Memorial Day Ceremories at the Legion
George
Ex- USAF
Thank you for spelling some things out that the media would rather we did not know. If we back out now what a waste of everything ( lives, money, time etc. ) it would be for nothing. How quickly some people forget the morning of Sept. 11,2001. It CAN happen again and maybe that is what needs to happen for some to realize the freedoms we take for granted every day. How long have the Iraqi people lived in fear to out the door every day to, play, and live? Keep up the good work and God bless all the soldiers and their families holding down the fort back home.
Thank You Sir
I know I will be speaking to the Republican Office in Johnstown to see who they are going to run against Murtha.
I do not feel at this time he will lose his seat. But I can not, NO I will not Vote for a man who asked that you be treated the way he was treated when he returned from Vietnam. You are all Heros and deserve to be treated that way and given the support of the Leadership in the State and federal level.
And the Media in this country can kiss my (_!_)
God Bless You and Gods Speed
To all of the soldiers USMC,28th ID, and everyone else
I know I will be speaking to the Republican Office in Johnstown to see who they are going to run against Murtha.
I do not feel at this time he will lose his seat. But I can not, NO I will not Vote for a man who asked that you be treated the way he was treated when he returned from Vietnam. You are all Heros and deserve to be treated that way and given the support of the Leadership in the State and federal level.
And the Media in this country can kiss my (_!_)
God Bless You and Gods Speed
To all of the soldiers USMC,28th ID, and everyone else
God bless you for being a voice of truth. I am so tired of hearing the lies and half-truths coming the the left. It sickens me to see people protesting the U.S. presence in Iraq while no one protest the evil and cowardly violence of the insurgents. Thank you for your courage, your commitment and I pray that God will be with you and keep you.
May all of you know the protection of God's angels as you go about your duties.
Know that you have a community of Catholic Sisters in the Texas Panhandle praying for you.
God bless you
Know that you have a community of Catholic Sisters in the Texas Panhandle praying for you.
God bless you
Major Vesely,
Many thanks for your eloquence and your service. My son Ryan is in Ramadi with a Marine MTT. In spite of media reporting, we believe in what you are doing and that America will prevail in enabling Iraqi's to shed their insurgency. Please know that politicians get the headlines, but we Americans get to vote. Our turn to send the politico's a headline is just around the corner. Thank you so much Sir.
Semper Fi
Tom
Ret Marine of 24 years service
Many thanks for your eloquence and your service. My son Ryan is in Ramadi with a Marine MTT. In spite of media reporting, we believe in what you are doing and that America will prevail in enabling Iraqi's to shed their insurgency. Please know that politicians get the headlines, but we Americans get to vote. Our turn to send the politico's a headline is just around the corner. Thank you so much Sir.
Semper Fi
Tom
Ret Marine of 24 years service
Thank you very much. I have a son over there with you all and I am very proud of what all of you are doing. I am impressed by what you said and I will pass it on. My thought and prayers are with all of you alway. Wanda Driggers
In response to Tom Canick- I have read your other posts on the Washington Post website. It is clear that your opinions are often thoughtless and factless, as other bloggers have continually responded to your comments on that site as such.
Here's the real ironic situation: you are disputing a major in the marines who is living the war in Iraq- despite the fact that you are sitting comfortably in your Rockville MD home. Who is more likely to have an accurate point of view? I wonder.
Here's a comment that you made just 16 months ago on the Washington Post website...
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A55677-2004Nov16.html
"It is with a heavy heart that I watch Colin L. Powell leave this administration. When President Bush took office in 2001, I did not count myself among his supporters. However, the addition of Mr. Powell changed my opinion.
Mr. Powell stood firm against the unilateralists in the administration and ensured that forces from Britain, Poland and other nations joined us in military action against Iraq.
And while the war has been a hard slog, the military and moral support that we have gained from our coalition allies has helped steel our resolve to see our task through to its successful end: a free, peaceful and prosperous Iraq.
TOM CANICK
Rockville"
I guess this is another example of "when the going gets tough, let's bail out and jump on the bandwagon that says its a bad idea".
Maj Vesley stated "Finally it means that the only way that we will fail to gain Victory is if WE give up."
It's a good thing we don't have people like you still in the armed forces, because you, like many of the public, have given up after just 16 months.
I am proud of our troops. Keep up the good work, and don't let people who have given up distract you from your accomplishments.
Here's the real ironic situation: you are disputing a major in the marines who is living the war in Iraq- despite the fact that you are sitting comfortably in your Rockville MD home. Who is more likely to have an accurate point of view? I wonder.
Here's a comment that you made just 16 months ago on the Washington Post website...
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A55677-2004Nov16.html
"It is with a heavy heart that I watch Colin L. Powell leave this administration. When President Bush took office in 2001, I did not count myself among his supporters. However, the addition of Mr. Powell changed my opinion.
Mr. Powell stood firm against the unilateralists in the administration and ensured that forces from Britain, Poland and other nations joined us in military action against Iraq.
And while the war has been a hard slog, the military and moral support that we have gained from our coalition allies has helped steel our resolve to see our task through to its successful end: a free, peaceful and prosperous Iraq.
TOM CANICK
Rockville"
I guess this is another example of "when the going gets tough, let's bail out and jump on the bandwagon that says its a bad idea".
Maj Vesley stated "Finally it means that the only way that we will fail to gain Victory is if WE give up."
It's a good thing we don't have people like you still in the armed forces, because you, like many of the public, have given up after just 16 months.
I am proud of our troops. Keep up the good work, and don't let people who have given up distract you from your accomplishments.
Thanks for the good words and good work. I think our country has always responded best in its darkest hours. Hopefully we, along with the Iraqis, will continue this struggle and history will vindicate us. All those negative, pessimistic opinions will be forgotten a decade from now while Iraq prospers under a peaceful democracy. God bless you all!
please pay no attention to this anti-American people whom you all are defending,we had the same anti -American pukes when i did my tours in Vietnam because we believed in freeing the Vietnamese people from what was a communist invasion of a free country,you all are our patriots of this generatrion. Thank you all for your loyal service to our way of life and bringing freedom to the Iraqi people.my wife and i have a personal interest in this war,our son kevin was in camp navistar and just came home ,our oldest son george is in ar ramadi .Semper Fi to you all from an old vietnam Marine.
Maj. Pay no attention to the forces of evil in this country. What John Kerry and others of his like, (socialists) say and thru their actions. I will work hard to defeat Murtha in his re-election, we may not get him this time, but all like him will have their day. Keep doing your job, focus on the mission, and take care of those Marines, and thank you.
Ltc(Ret.)Kenneth Ault
Ltc(Ret.)Kenneth Ault
Thank you so much for your efforts, Major, and those of your men.
Tom Canik is only half wrong when he says: " I believe that you will fail in your mission to establish a secure and stable Iraq"
I believe the only way that a secure and stable Iraq is established, is thru the work, sacrifice, and heroism, of Iraqis.
Your mission, that you accepted in joining, is to support the pro-democracy Iraqis in establishing that secure Iraq.
Such an Iraq will have many heros -- Iraqi heros. Heros with family survivors; heros who volunteered, heros who died. Iraqis who died for the future, secure, Iraq.
And yes, America helped. Maybe even did heavy lifting BUT it will be Iraqis who do the heavy dying. Who ARE doing the heavy dying.
Please consider rethinking your Rule of Might phrase, I believe Rule of Fear would be a better one for demonization (from Sharkansky). Because, obviously, the US has the Might to win any battle. So our, your, opposition is not to Rule of Might, but to Rule of Fear, Rulers without accountability, Rules without respect for human rights, Rules by whims of Rulers.
Please keep trying to get a bit more publicity -- has your father submitted your letters to his local newspaper? The blog is great (first visitor, tonight; via Winds of Change).
Fight Evil. Win.
God Bless You.
Post a Comment
Tom Canik is only half wrong when he says: " I believe that you will fail in your mission to establish a secure and stable Iraq"
I believe the only way that a secure and stable Iraq is established, is thru the work, sacrifice, and heroism, of Iraqis.
Your mission, that you accepted in joining, is to support the pro-democracy Iraqis in establishing that secure Iraq.
Such an Iraq will have many heros -- Iraqi heros. Heros with family survivors; heros who volunteered, heros who died. Iraqis who died for the future, secure, Iraq.
And yes, America helped. Maybe even did heavy lifting BUT it will be Iraqis who do the heavy dying. Who ARE doing the heavy dying.
Please consider rethinking your Rule of Might phrase, I believe Rule of Fear would be a better one for demonization (from Sharkansky). Because, obviously, the US has the Might to win any battle. So our, your, opposition is not to Rule of Might, but to Rule of Fear, Rulers without accountability, Rules without respect for human rights, Rules by whims of Rulers.
Please keep trying to get a bit more publicity -- has your father submitted your letters to his local newspaper? The blog is great (first visitor, tonight; via Winds of Change).
Fight Evil. Win.
God Bless You.
<< Home


